What your numbers can and can’t tell you
QuietStrength Body shows you a few numbers. Here’s what I think they’re good for, and where they run out.
Your weight moves every day. It goes up and down with water, food, salt, sleep and hormones. That’s why the app shows weekly averages, so the everyday ups and downs don’t take over.
The scale can’t tell you what changed. From one day to the next, most of the change is water. Over several weeks, a change can be muscle as well as fat, and the number on its own won’t say which.
Home scales estimate body fat and muscle. They’re consistent from one reading to the next, but any single reading can be a few points out. Trends over several weeks are far more useful than one number.¹
Getting stronger doesn’t always show on the scale. If you start strength training, your weight may stay much the same, or move a little either way, while you get stronger. That’s normal, and your clothes may fit differently before any number moves.
Sleep can affect your weight too. Like food, salt and stress, it can change how your weight moves from day to day.
A simple record helps you see how things are going. Research suggests that keeping track helps people who are working towards aims of their own.² QuietStrength Body leaves the aims to you. It doesn’t set targets, and there are no streaks.
It isn’t a medical device. If something changes a lot and you don’t know why, speak to a qualified healthcare professional.
Sources
¹ Siedler MR et al. Assessing the reliability and cross-sectional and longitudinal validity of fifteen bioelectrical impedance analysis devices. British Journal of Nutrition 2023;130(5):827–840. doi:10.1017/S0007114522003749
² Harkin B et al. Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin 2016;142(2):198–229. doi:10.1037/bul0000025
The rules the app uses
Weekly averages
Daily readings bounce around, so trends use weekly averages.
Steady bands
Weight, fat mass and lean mass within about 1 kg, body fat within about 1 point, waist under 2 cm: steady.
Sleep: 5 of 7 nights
With fewer nights recorded, Body says “Not enough nights yet”.
Sleep: 45 minutes
A change is mentioned only when your week is 45 min or more from your 28-night usual.
Estimates
Body fat and lean mass from home scales are estimates, and shown as such.
Hide weight
Turn off “Show weight and body fat” and those numbers are hidden everywhere.
QuietStrength Body helps you record and understand information about your body and sleep. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you’re concerned about your health or about information you see in Body, speak to a qualified healthcare professional.
If keeping an eye on your body is causing you distress, Body may not be right for you right now. Beat (beateatingdisorders.org.uk) offers support.